Pay with your wallet balance and get cashback on every order.
Best New York-Style Pizza in Tarpon Springs, Florida
Hot-baked New York-style pizza with a crisp, foldable slice. Try a Calzone with a side of marinara, then finish with Cannoli filled to order.
Order directly from us and support local businesses. Plus, you'll get the best prices and service!
Discover
Grandma's Pizza is a great place to start if you like a crisp-edged, square slice with a sturdy bite. It’s built to hold up from the first piece to the last, even when you’re sharing. If you want something with a little heat, go with Buffalo Chicken. It’s a straightforward combo of chicken, spice, and melted cheese that eats like a full meal. Make it a simple two-item order: one Grandma's Pizza for the table plus one Buffalo Chicken for anyone who wants a spicier slice. You’ll cover both classic and bold without overthinking the order.
Discover
Use our site to order online and build your meal at your own pace. Start with pizza, add sides, and check out in a few taps. Pickup and delivery are both available, and you can schedule ahead when you want dinner handled before the rush. Checkout supports Apple Pay and Google Pay, so you can pay quickly without re-typing your card details on your phone. If you’re ordering for a group, it’s easy to repeat favorites and keep the order moving.
Discover
Catering makes it easy to feed a group without turning your event into a logistics project. Set up pizza trays and sides for an office lunch, a birthday, a team meeting, or a family gathering. A Calzone option is a good fit when you need a handheld item that stays warm and travels well. Add salads, wings, and desserts to round out the table so there’s something for everyone. Place a catering order online, tell us how many people you’re feeding, and we’ll help you choose a mix that works for your group and timing.
Discover
Join our Loyalty Program and get rewarded for the orders you’re already placing. You earn 1 point per dollar, and new accounts start with a 25-point sign-up bonus. If you like stamp-style rewards, the Stamp Card is simple: collect 12 stamps and earn a $10 reward. It also starts you off with 2 pre-filled stamps. Rewards are made for regular pizza nights, quick lunches, and family orders. Sign in while you order so your points and stamps track automatically.
Discover
Rick's NY Pizza & Restaurant serves Tarpon Springs, Florida with dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Restaurant hours run 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Sunday through Thursday, and 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday. Call 727-934-5297 for help with a large order, menu questions, or special requests. If you’re headed in, you’ll find us on East Klosterman Road with easy access for quick pickup when you’re trying to keep dinner on schedule.
Discover
Rick's NY Pizza & Restaurant focuses on straightforward New York-style pies, Italian classics, and consistent portions. Stop in on East Klosterman Road in Tarpon Springs, Florida for dine-in, takeout, or delivery.
Gallery
A glimpse into our restaurant and cuisine
+3
View All Photos
+1
View All Photos
Reviews
Real experiences from our valued customers
“Excellent pizza, excellent cannoli, and excellent service from Josh. Made me feel like I was back in the north end of Boston instead of Florida. The almond cranberry salad was good, and I loved the Sicilian crust, and the atmosphere was so nostalgic and fun.”
Verified Customer
“Came for an early dinner and had the most delicious eggplant parm I’ve ever had. It was fried crispy, topped with a ton of mozz and super tasty sauce… added a side of sautéed broccoli … such a large portion that I have plenty for dinner tomorrow as well. My son got Honey BBQ boneless wings and fries and devoured it. Josh our server was awesome. We couldn’t have wished for a nicer time out. They were decorated really cute too for the holidays! ”
Verified Customer
“Tried Rick’s for lunch today and WOW. The pizza was perfect—crispy crust with garlic butter that hit just right. The homemade ranch was unreal. Took leftovers home and even my kids loved it. Safe to say I’ll be back… for work lunches and family nights”
Verified Customer
Our Story
The story behind our commitment to excellence
The first pick for many regulars is Grandma's Pizza. It bakes up with a crisp edge, a sturdy square slice, and a balanced layer of sauce and cheese that holds its bite without turning soggy. Add Garlic Knots to the order for something warm and simple alongside your pizza. They’re baked until golden and brushed so they stay tender in the middle. Find Rick's at 905 East Klosterman Road in Tarpon Springs, Florida, and grab a pie for the table or a quick takeout dinner on the way home. If you’re feeding a group, these two make an easy starting lineup that covers both the main and the shareable side.
Lunch works well here when you want something filling without a long sit-down. A Buffalo Chicken pizza keeps it straightforward: chicken, heat, and a cheesy finish that eats like a full meal. Dinner is easy for families because the menu has familiar Italian staples and plenty of options to share. Keep it simple with pizza for the table, or mix in a few extras so everyone gets something they like. Later in the evening, the same idea holds up. You can keep it casual in the dining room or take it back home, and the food still travels well when you want something hot and substantial.
Rick's is part of the weekly routine for a lot of Tarpon Springs families, from quick weeknight dinners to weekend meals after a day out. You’ll see locals grabbing a pie for home, meeting up for a relaxed table, or picking up dinner on the way through town. The kitchen turns out straightforward New York-style pizza with consistent portions and familiar Italian options, which is why people keep it in rotation. If you’re craving pizza in Tarpon Springs, Florida, this is a reliable stop with easy access from around town and delivery service that reaches places like the Sponge Docks, Palm Harbor, and Dunedin.
If you want to round out the meal, go beyond a single pie and build a full spread. Traditional Wings are a solid add-on when you need something savory that isn’t another slice, especially for groups watching a game or sharing dinner. Garlic Knots work well as a table starter or as an extra side for dipping and snacking between slices. They’re simple, warm, and easy to split. For dessert, Cannoli is the classic finish. It’s sweet without being heavy, and it makes the meal feel complete when you’re ordering for family or bringing food back to the house. If you want an easy handheld option, a Calzone is a good choice when you’d rather keep everything contained while still getting that hot, baked crust and filling.
Discover
New York-Style Pizza And Italian Classics
Rick's NY Pizza & Restaurant serves hand-stretched pizzas baked in an oven over 600 degrees, plus Italian favorites that work for lunch or a full family dinner.
Dine in, take out, or get delivery when you want a hot meal without cooking.
Place your order for pickup when you want dinner on your timeline. Pickup estimated time is 20 minutes.
Delivery is available for Tarpon Springs and nearby areas. Delivery estimated time is 40 minutes.
Catering is available for office lunches, parties, and family gatherings. Fast checkout is available, including Apple Pay and Google Pay.
Get a classic pie for sharing, add a few sides, and finish with dessert when you want the full spread without a long wait.
See the full menu, then build an order that works for one person or a whole group.
View Full MenuFAQ
Find answers to common questions about our restaurant
Simply click on 'Order Online' or 'Start Your Order' button, browse our menu, add items to your cart, and proceed to checkout. You can pay online or choose to pay at pickup/delivery.
Our hours vary by day. Please check the 'Hours' section on our homepage for the most up-to-date information.
Yes! We offer delivery within our delivery zone. Delivery fees and minimum order requirements may apply. Check our online ordering page for details.
For reservations, please call us directly or use our contact form. We'll do our best to accommodate your party.
Yes, we offer catering services for events of all sizes. Please go to our catering form to request a quote.
Get in Touch
We'd love to hear from you. Send us a message and we'll respond as soon as possible.
